Everything that is wrong with the 24-hour news cycle – Opinion

As published in Semper Floreat.

Earlier this week, Australia stopped to look at a madman. We stopped to look at him because all of our news outlets told us to. He was doing something shocking and scary and so every news reporter, cameraman, and anchor pointed their fingers towards this man, and screamed at us to LOOK LOOK LOOK!


From the moment authorities and newsrooms got wind that this person, now known as Man Haron Monis, had taken a then-unknown number of hostages in a Sydney café, the ‘rolling coverage’ began.

Now, don’t get me wrong, rolling coverage is great for some news events, like election nights, when votes are being counted and there is enough material to justify constant reporting. For Monday’s slow-moving and high-tension situation, however, all newsrooms did was broadcast a tidal wave of garbage that clogged up our newsfeeds and, most crucially, obscured actual facts. With little action occurring on the ground for most of the day, our television channels, newspapers and Twitter feeds flooded with speculation, sensational rumours, and unconfirmed reports, all designed to glue eyeballs to screens and fill otherwise dead air.

Take, for example, reports that Monis was tied to the terrorist organisation Islamic State. Shortly after taking the café staff and patrons hostage, Monis forced hostages to hold up a black flag with a proclamation of Islamic faith in Arabic, the Shahada. Subsequent reports featured headlines such as Death Cult CBD Attack (Daily Telegraph) and Islamic State-linked terror grips city (Financial Review).


Also making the list of media failures were the reports of Sydney Airport and airspace above Martin Place being closed, the enormous song-and-dance made about US President Barack Obama being briefed, and the Sydney Morning Herald’s inexcusably pointless report that Monis ‘might be’ in possession of a bomb. Even the mudslinging outrage over ride-sharing company Uber’s raised fares contributed to the atmosphere of intentionally induced panic. Were reports of Sydney airport being closed verified by the airport itself? No, not until later. Was Obama’s briefing integral to understanding the events at Martin Place? No. Was Uber the only way one could evacuate themselves from a collapsing city swarming with IS militants, as the Telegraph would have you believe? Nope. And was there any good reason whatsoever to whip the population of Sydney in a fearful lather with Monis’s claims (which the police requested not be shared by the media) of having planted bombs around the city?  Absolutely not.


Granted, several newsrooms did report responsibly and ethically, and I applaud Channel 7’s decision not to broadcast footage taken while aiding the police sniper team. I applaud 2GB’s Ray Hadley and ABC TV for taking calls from hostages off-air and immediately deferring to police. I appreciate, as I’m sure loved ones of the siege’s victims also do, the blurring out of the hostage’s faces inside the café.But there were many mistakes, there were many blatant cries for attention and many misinformed idiots were given free license to broadcast trash. And in broadcasting this trash, the majority of Australia’s commercial news media let down not just their viewers, but the hostages, law enforcement, and the nation. We’re an adult nation, and we need to re-evaluate how we react when an event like this occurs in our capital cities. Do we acknowledge that any attempts at terrorism relies heavily on media attention, that focusing all eyes on a lunatic with a shotgun is exactly what said lunatic wants, and report events ethically with that in mind? Or do we gawk and fuss over this madman, addicted to ‘breaking news’ and anxiously tuning into 24-hour channels filled with nothing but speculation, accomplishing and learning nothing of value?The vast majority of our news outlets seem to think the latter is more appropriate; that that’s what we’d prefer. The best possible way we can honour the victims of Monis’s senseless violence, ourselves, and the once-proud institution of Australian journalism, is to tell them, as loudly and clearly as we can, exactly how wrong they are.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s